Mako Guitar Picks Review – Guitar Picks From Outer Space

Photo of author

By Guitar Pick Reviews

James Barros started making guitar picks in 2018 and launched Mako Guitar Picks at the end of 2022. He is known in the community for his original pick shape, the Mako, which he came up with in 2020.

As an obsessive guitar picks geek, I try to follow as many guitar pick makers as possible to ensure I don’t miss anything interesting. The second I saw Mako Picks’ Instagram profile, I was hooked. His designs and color choices just hit all my buttons. By the second or third post I saw, I sent him a message, and a couple of days later, the picks were already on their way.

Mako Guitar Picks
Mako Guitar Picks

The Mako Guitar Picks I’m Reviewing Today

For this review, I have 11 picks:

  • Jumbo Mako – 10.5mm thick resin pick.
  • 3 Acrylic picks – 2.7mm small, medium, and large picks.
  • 5 Resin picks – four large and one medium 2.5mm thick picks, all matte finished.
  • 2 Flat thins – unbeveled clear 1.2mm thick picks.
Mako Guitar Picks
Mako Guitar Picks

The ‘Mako’ Shape

Beyond how cool the Mako shape looks, it’s pretty clever, too. It features two playing tips and a “gripping arm”. This design makes you hold a Mako differently than how you hold other guitar picks. This way utilizes the gripping arm to keep the pick in place and to prevent it from moving. Mako’s tips are another interesting feature. The wide one is slightly narrower than the tip of Flow picks, and the slim tip is one of the narrowest I’ve ever seen. When I just started playing with it, I thought I wouldn’t like it too much. To my surprise, as time went on, I found myself using it more and more until I ended up favoring it over the conventional one.

See also  Dunlop Rock III - My New Favorite Custom Jazz III - Full Review

Mako Guitar Picks Rundown

Now, we’re going to go over each of the four models I have in more detail.

Jumbo Mako

The Jumbo Mako is made of Resin. It has 2 playing tips and another gripping arm. On each side, it has a sharp bevel leading to the tip and a large flat area in the middle.

Mako Jumbo Guitar Pick
Mako Jumbo Guitar Pick

Mako Acrylic Picks

Mako’s Acrylic line is very well made and available in three sizes: small, medium, and large. They are very fun picks to play with, and the narrow tip is surprisingly useful. I found it a bit hard to hold the small and medium ones in a way that will utilize the gripping arm. Thanks to their unique shape, the grip is great even when you hold them like you would any other pick.

Small, Medium, and Large Mako Acrylic Guitar Picks
Small, Medium, and Large Mako Acrylic Guitar Picks

Mako Resin Picks

The Resin picks have a rougher texture than the Acrylic ones. It helps with the grip but can sometimes make them sound a bit muffed, at least compared to the Acrylic ones.

Mako Resin Guitar Picks
Mako Resin Guitar Picks

Unbeveled Thin Picks

Honestly, I hated them the first time I tried them. It took them a few minutes to break in, but once they did, I fell in love. The fact that there’s no bevel makes them scratch the strings with each pluck, making a clean guitar sound very eastern. It affected how I played, forcing me to revisit the In Sen and Hirajoshi scales for the first time in the last couple of years. I started playing around noon, and after a couple of minutes, it was already dark outside.

Mako Thin Guitar Picks
Mako Thin Guitar Picks


Even though the sizing is straightforward (the small is similar to Jazz III, the medium is closer to John Petrucci’s Jazz III, and the large is about the size of a Flow), It’s hard to estimate how much space you need for utilizing the gripping arm. I mostly use the large size, but my fingers are quite chubby.

See also  Dunlop Jazz III - Review - The Best Pick Of All Time?
Mako Picks Sizing Chart Small, Medium, and Large Mako Picks Next to Jazz III, Jazz III XL, John petrucci's Jazz III, Flow, Flow Jumbo and Tortex Standard
Small, Medium, and Large Mako Picks Next to Jazz III, Jazz III XL, John Petrucci’s Jazz III, Flow, Flow Jumbo, and Tortex Standard

What Else is In The Mako Range

Every now and then, James adds a new shape to his collection, like the recent Jazz picks. Following him on Instagram would be a good idea if it interests you.

Pricing and Where to Get them From?

I appreciate the simplicity of pricing in Mako’s shop. The jumbo costs $25, and all the other thinner picks cost $20 for a pack of 5. All are available from his Etsy shop.

Finishing Thoughts

The shape itself is stunning, and any one of these picks is definitely a conversation starter. Having two tips to choose from is another obvious advantage it has over other picks. The Resin and Acrylic are pretty easy to get used to, but the Thin model is very harsh before it’s broken in.

Let’s take a moment to acknowledge the Jombo, one of the most unique, outrageous, surprisingly comfortable, and one of my personal favorite picks. It does require some getting used to, but once you get there, it’s hard to put it down, even if you’re not that into thicker guitar picks.

Mako Guitar Picks - Final Score

8.2 Highly Recommended

They sound pretty much in line with what you can expect from the materials, except for the thin unbeveled ones, which sound phenomenal, in my opinion. They feel great, and the Jumbo feels superb. One of the most comfortable picks I've ever tried. The durability is above average, as expected from these materials, except for the thin ones that wear a bit faster because they are unbeveled. The grip is amazing thanks to the unique shape, and the price is very reasonable.

See also  Thalia Picks - Full Review
  • Sound 8
  • Feel 10
  • Durability 7
  • Grip 8
  • Price 8